The related texts reviewed include The Arrival’ (Shawn Tan, 2006) graphic novel which Illustrates a visual story of an immigrant who leaves home to create a better life for his family and the play ‘Away (Michael Go, 1993). Thus It may be ascertained, that belonging defines who we are. In the poem of ‘Fillies Crooknecks’ Peter Crooknecks explores filial relationships. This issue is highlighted between Fillies and Peter Crooknecks, a cultural barrier exists between them as a result of their different cultural backgrounds, education and a generation gap.Fillies observes this tragic gap developing which Is revealed in the mile “After that, like a dumb prophet, watched me pegging my tents” (stanza 7, lines 5-6) this reinforces the poet’s feelings of Isolation and distance from his parent’s heritage.
Fillies is powerless to speak out about his son’s movement away from him through his lack of English language. He is visionary as he can foresee that peter will come to value his heritage in later years. The consequences of Fillies not belonging in Australia is the separation between himself and his son they have cultural barriers as he Is growing up and becoming familiar with Australian culture.In addition another example of this Is “Talking, they reminisced about farms where paddocks flowered… ” (Stanza 3 lines 6-7) This illustrates how Peter Crooknecks is excluded from conversations involving his father about Poland and the past as he is not a part of it.
The exclusive pronoun they’ highlights his separation with his father Fillies. Fillies has strong emotional ties to his polish heritage and belongs to his past therefore this creates consequences as his bond with his past is a barrier to belonging. Filial relationships with different groups without a doubt define who we are.To a certain extent filial relationships with different groups helps define who we are. Filial relationships occur in the graphic novel The Arrival’ through the main character the father as he experiences difficulty fleeing his country to escape and to create a better life for him and his family. He struggles to find employment and a place to stay, and has problems trying to understand his new environment. A strange alien idea, this is seen as the white origami bird which befriends the father this appears throughout the text as a reminder to the father of where he has come from and as an inspiration to continue through difficult times.
In another instance the arrival realizes that he is not alone in his search for a place to belong. He listens to other immigrants speak of their traumatic experiences; these experiences are translated for the reader in a series of flashbacks. The flashbacks are highlighted in the text through the darkening of the sepia tone to suggest the past, as well as the pain. This has effect of bonding the arrival to people with his new environment and slowly creating a place where he can belong.The consequences and affects of not belonging is that the arrival who is a migrant cannot understand his new environment so the process of belong can be slow and difficult and the arrivals separation from his loved ones makes belonging even more difficult. Filial relationships with different groups without a doubt define who we are. Furthermore, the lack of spirituality and religion affects his place in belonging as a student.
In the poem ‘SST Patriot’s college’ the poet explores the effects of not belonging, and his physical existence within the school; however there are clear visions in him not belonging in his schooling environment.This is portrayed throughout the last stanza as Crooknecks use of tone to emphasis his spiritual detachment from the religion practiced at school. This highlights the isolation -which had been most strongly introduced at the beginning in the distancing between mother and son which also gives a visual dimension in the sight of the boy “with closed eyes” (stanza 5, line 6). This is also demonstrated “l walked Chesterfield’s paths and streets… Eke a foreign tourist” (stanza 3, lines 2-6) it is clear that Crooknecks hectically as he “walks the streets of Stratified and catches the 414 bus” This demonstrates how Peter Crooknecks acts as a student of SST Patrick and he performs a similar ritual as most of the students.
However, the line “like a foreign tourist” This highlights that he is emotionally detached. He is emotionally disconnected because of his lack of engagement with his religious education. The simile used reinforces the deeper meaning that he is doing all the normal you would as a person within that group, but emotionally his lost like a foreign tourist.To a certain extent the different groups we belong to define who we are, however there are times when a certain group can separate you from belonging. As explored in the poem ‘SST Patrick’ by Peter Crooknecks, the text ‘Away by Michael Go similarly displays the aspect of belonging physically but not emotionally. This is experienced where three families embark on Journeys which lead to them to belonging. This is manifested in Coral as she is physically existent in her holiday but not emotionally as she is suffering from the death of her son who died for his country ND was chosen to defend his country.
Coral repeats this idea showing her lack of interest in anything else that is happening in her life as this is more important this is shown in “Vie been having a terrific time. We’ve been talking about the standard of living in this country. Coral further repeats the same idea of the war and the outcomes which was achieved through the death of her son in the war. Additionally behave in a way that’s too… Weird for my liking.
I can feel people watching us walk away thinking, how much longer before he has to lock up the poor rutabaga wife up?Michael Go uses rhetorical question to reinforce his point of view to not Just Coral his wife but the audience also. These demonstrate how Coral is physically existent in their holiday away together but not emotionally as she is separated from reality as she can’t move forward from the death of her son and wants to blame the government for the death of her son. Therefore to a certain extent different groups we belong to define who we are, however there are times when a certain group can separate you from belonging and mimes where you can physically belong to a group but not always emotionally belong particular environment’.