Comparing Roles of Antipholus S. and Antipholus E.
A Comedy of Errors Comparing Roles: Antipholus of Ephesus and Antipholus of Syracuse The Comedy of Errors: Comparing Roles of Antipholus of Ephesus and Antipholus of Syracuse “The Comedy of Errors” expresses the story of two sets of identical twins that were unintentionally separated at birth. Antipholus of Syracuse and his man servant, Dromio of Syracuse, arrive in Ephesus (which is a neighboring merchant country), which turns out to be the home of their twin brothers, Antipholus of Ephesus and his man servant, Dromio of Ephesus.
When Antipholus and Dromio of Syracuse encounter the friends and families of their counterparts, a series of wild ishaps occur. Mistaken identities lead to unfair beatings, a near-seduction, the detention of Antipholus of Ephesus, and untruthful accusations of infidelity, robbery, insanity, and demonic possession. Through these unfortunate mistakes and series of comical mishaps we find Antipholus of Ephesus and Antipholus of Syracuse two wonderful characters to compare and contrast throughout the play. Antipholus of Ephesus has an entirely conventional (domestic) life in Ephesus.
He has a home of his own where he lives with his wife Adriana and his sister-in-law Luciana. Antipholus ppears to know every person there is to know within the city of Ephesus. Antipholus has created a reputable reputation with his community that he worked hard to build and has indeed accomplished. Antipholus E. , unlike his brother, pays no life he has created for himself and his wife. Antipholus E. is also a man labeled within his own household as one to have a “quick to anger” temper. His relationship with Dromio of Ephesus tends to exhibit a servant-master relationship and not one of a great distinguished friendship.
Antipholus of Syracuse is the “younger” half of the set of long-separated identical twins. He was primarily raised by his father, Egeon, in Syracuse, after being separated from his mother and brother. Antipholus of Syracuse’s only traveling companion is his “bondsman,” (or man servant) Dromio of Syracuse, who is the servant boy his father bought to be his companion and attendant when both Antipholus’s were newborn babies. As soon as Antipholus turned eighteen, he developed an “inquisitive” longing to find out more about his missing twin brother, and along with Dromio of Syracuse, left his father to go search for their respective other halves.
Egeon explicitly states the nature of his son Antipholus S, by stating to the Duke, oungest boy, and yet my eldest care, became inquisitive, “Egeon. My At eighteen years After his brother, and importuned That his attendant”so his case was like, Reft of his brother but retained his name– Might bear him company in the quest of him… ” Antipholus E. on the other hand, gives us constant reminders that he was a warrior and founded a life for himself, he states more than once that he was brought to the country by the Duke and swears loyalty to him, “Ant. E.
I come from Corinth, my most gracious lord …. Brought to this town by the most famous warrior Duke Menaphon, your most renowned uncle. This statement signifies to the reader that the Antiphulos brothers share different ideas and perspectives on where they place loyalties and priorities. Antipholus E. is grounded as a prosperous merchant, has sworn loyalties and oaths to the Duke, and places his material objects first. He considers possessions such as fine Jewelry to be something of worth to his character and prides himself on being able to provide these items to his wife.
He dwells in the delight of having made such a fine name for himself and excepts the entitlement that proceeds such a endearment. Antipholus S. places his loyalty in his family bonds nd makes his priority a quest to find missing members. He is not grounded like his brother nor has he placed material objects at the fore front of his priorities. Antipholus S places no value on his Jewelry and clothing alike and merely wants to be happy with what he has. He is a wonderer of sorts and depicts a man that is does not care whether he is known and admired.
Antipholus of Syracuse also seems to have a drifting and inquisitive soul. In addition to his desire to travel, he’s branded by a grave loneliness and feels as if he is missing something. He proclaims he feels alone without knowing his mother and brother. However, he seems to want to seek them to create some part of his identity that cannot be formed until they are found. Antipholus of Ephesus can scarcely be described as anything but a “negative” energy within the play. His temper is discernibly violent, and with little aggravation.
We discover that when he is truly upset by his confinement by Pinch and his followers; the extent of his violent reaction actually does indicate that he may be somewhat mentally unstable, and not Just as an outcome of the day’s mishaps and occurrences. Pinch after escaping from bondage at Pinch’s home. Instead of running for safety like ost captives would do, Antipholus attacks and is will to torture in return. This signifies a lack of conscious towards remorse. Antipholus also addresses his wife early in the play and is instantly angered because he cannot enter into his home and he states, “Ant.
E. And buy a rope’s end: that will I bestow Among my wife and her confederates, For locking me out of my doors by day. ”” This brings to light further proof of his temper and unhappiness with his wife. When he is locked out of his home, as his wife and Adriana are dining with Antipholus S. , he becomes irritated and goes to dine at the Courtesan’s house instead. He also asks Angelo (a fine Jewelry maker) to complete the chain he prearranged for his wife (in attempt to appease his wrongs), so that instead he can give it to the Courtesan to spite his wife. He further states, “Ant. E. [To Ang. Get you home, chain; that chain will I bestow” wife” And fetch the to the Porpentine; Be it for nothing but to spite my Upon mine hostess there: good sir, make haste. Since mine own doors refuse to entertain me, I’ll knock elsewhere, to see if theyll disdain me. ” Antipholus E. does nearly nothing to gain the understanding of the reader throughout the course of the play, and really only in his inal long speech, where he realistically recounts the day’s many misfortunes, does he indicate that he has indeed been distressed much more than beyond a school- boyish irritation. An actor may bestow Antipholus E. ith respectable emotions during this final scene; however, his dialogue still indicates very little to no sentiment towards his new found brother and father. Could it be that because Antipholus grew up and identified a connection that filled his emptiness towards missing family with the Duke’s friendship, that he feels he has no need to find a blood family, for he has found a new family? Antipholus E. entions not a single word to his long-lost brother that has now been reunited with him before they exit together to enter the Abbey where they have also Just found their mother, the abbess.