Intergenerational Conflicts Essay Sample
In all sorts of ethic groups in the United States. Asiatic Americans such as Chinese and Indians are considered as the largest immigrant group. Although struggles are inevitable between parents and kids. immigrant households face more challenges in intergenerational struggles. and there are several grounds. First of all. the dissension of different values and premises between two civilizations chiefly cause household struggles. For Chinese immigrant parents. they follow the Confucian values. which emphasizes filial piousness. difficult work. service and accomplishments in instruction and businesss as criterions in lives ( Foner. p. 21 ) ; nevertheless. kids who are born and raise in American civilization. seek more independency and freedom for their ain facets. and bulk consequences against their parents. Furthermore. issues of subject and regard may easy make spreads between coevalss.
For the 2nd coevalss. who are reared in American civilization and garbage to follow the regulations and origin civilization. see their parents as old-fashion and chesty.
Only $13.90 / page
and “ [ T ] he parents. with their ( sometimes idealized ) old universe criterions. frequently think their kids are ill-mannered and disrespectful ” ( Foner. p. 5 ) . Besides. transcending outlooks and inabilities of linguistic communication reading for some immigrant parents besides struggle the relationships with their kids ( Lieber. p. 35 ) . Even though intergenerational struggles in immigrant households in the U. S. may weaken the relationship between parents and kids. as kids grow up as grownups. those struggles really help beef up the relationship in the long tally.
Intergenerational struggles may do negative effects for both parents and kids. Discrepancies of heat from parents may act upon the attitude of immigrant kids in a negative manner. For illustration. some Asiatic immigrant parents such as India are non really expressive with their kids physically and emotionally. and this makes Asiatic American striplings. who have been taught to evidently express feelings. think their parents are non demoing the heat to them as the manner they expect ( Wu. p. 516 ) . Furthermore. for immigrant parents. they intend to rule their kids in beliefs and behaviours due to the fright of losing beginning. A psychological science survey shows that “ [ P ] arents who were socialized throughout their childhood and early maturity in their state of beginning are likely to hold a stable and established sense of Asiatic individuality “ ( Wang. p. 169 ) . and they besides expect their kids to take part and accomplish good in American civilization. As a consequence. struggles of high outlooks to keep two different civilizations and outstanding accomplishment would easy do mental emphasis. depression and anxiousness for immigrant striplings.
For illustration. an probe shows that “ Korean American college pupils who perceived their parents as extremely traditional ( stressing cultural values ) reported more depressive symptoms ” ( Wu. p. 517 ) . and another survey besides indicates that “Young people in Filipino and Chinese households are under enormous force per unit area from their parents to acquire good classs. to graduate from college. and to prosecute “practical” callings such as jurisprudence. medical specialty. or technology “ ( Foner. p. 6 ) . On the other manus. non merely kids. immigrant parents would besides be affected negatively. For case. children’s marginalisation of keeping original civilization would do great defeat to immigrant parents. and even the failure in academic public presentation would besides do them experience shame on the hapless kids. who consider themselves “working at least twice every bit difficult as their American equals while experiencing that their parents ne’er think they work difficult enough” ( Foner. p. 6 ) . Therefore. normally. people assume that the relationship between immigrant parents and kids would be earnestly affected and weakened due to these negative effects.
However. when 2nd coevalss grow up as grownups. those struggles they had before would do both parents and kids change their point of position about each other and bit by bit develop better socialization and accommodations. First of all. even though the intergenerational struggles in immigrant households cause many statements. dissatisfactions. defeats. and even depressions between parents and kids. their relationship does non truly interrupt apart as we thought. In a instance survey. the writer explains. “even when immature people chafe under parental restraints and duties. the huge bulk feel deep fondness for and trueness to their parents and grandparents and acknowledge the importance of household and the demand to help and back up household members “ ( Foner. p. 8 ) . and the household really “ create [ s ] strong emotional ties that bond members together “ ( Foner. p. 8 ) although it is non evidently shown from parents and kids. Therefore. when kids become grownups. their ways of thought would alter and may get down believing maturely.
For illustration. for Chinese immigrant households. filial duty. which emphasizes the importance of attention for and back uping each household member. plays an highly of import function in Chinese values ( Diwan. p. 55 ) . Undoubtedly. Chinese immigrant parents would extremely anticipate their kids to prolong this duty even though their kids are Americanized. As for immigrant striplings. who have already been pressured by other outlooks from their parents. may make marginalisation and do household struggles ; nevertheless. every bit turning as grownups and confronting the world of the universe. they may reflect those struggles in the yesteryear and acknowledge the importance of back uping and caring household. Besides. they may get down to understand why their parents insist to keep the traditions and beliefs in their host civilization ( Diwan. p. 58 ) .
Besides. as kids turning up. immigrant parents’ point of position would besides go different from before. For case. since immigrant kids are still developing their features. some immigrant parents set up rigorous parental counsel in order to set up and determine their children’s personalities or perceptual experiences in the manner they expect ; however. after their kids become grownups. some parents may non be every bit rigorous as earlier due to the belief that their kids are able to be responsible for their ain lives. In the instance of altering point of positions. both parents and kids would get down seeking to accept different beliefs from each other. and mentally. socialization and accommodations would be successfully formed.
Furthermore. after altering point of position. behaviours would besides accordingly change to organize a better relationship between immigrant coevalss. Since the point of position has become different and both parents and kids become more willing to accept the differences. their behaviours would bit by bit alter for rapprochement ; in other words. to beef up intergenerational relationship. For parents. they become more flexible in subject. non every bit stubborn as they used to be. For case. “ widening the eventide curfew hr. or allowing dating earlier than some parents would wish “ ( Foner. p. 8 ) ; besides. picks of calling. involvements. and even marriage agreement can besides be negotiated. which is different from the yesteryear that kids are expected to obey their parents’ determinations without expostulations. A research about rearing patterns among Indian immigrant households indicates that “ some parents are seeking to larn new ways to train their kids ; some are larning new techniques from their kids. who explain how American or Americanized friends are disciplined “ ( Foner. p. 8 ) . and this survey shows that immigrant parents are seeking to alter themselves in order to acquire closer to their kids.
Furthermore. as for the 2nd coevalss. unlike the clip as striplings. alternatively of preferring to be entirely with friends. they behave more caring about household members and voluntarily supply support when there is a demand. For illustration. linguistic communication barriers were used to be one of the struggles among some immigrant parents and kids. However. after the alteration of point of position. some Chinese 2nd coevalss no longer experience shame about their parents’ inabilities of linguistic communication reading. and an probe shows that some 2nd coevalss become more willing to assist their parents cover with linguistic communication job. and some immigrant parents even better their linguistic communication ability from their turning kids ( Costigan. p. 1253 ) . Besides. for some immigrant Asian-American authors. who realize their individuality in two different civilizations. appreciate their parents and portion their grasp by composing kids books. and “many of them write about their past defeat of populating two different civilizations every bit good as usage narratives to show their new grasp of the hard- ships their parents and grandparents endured and of the cultural civilization they transmitted “ ( Mo. p. 182 ) .
Truong Tran. a Vietnamese-American author who has immigrated to the U. S since the age of five. writes an debut in the book Going Home. Coming Home that “ It took me 25 old ages to return—to Vietnam. and to myself as a Vietnamese. In making so. I discovered myself as an American. I am non one or the other but in fact both… It is a narrative of detecting that place is non a topographic point rooted in a state but a feeling rooted in the bosom ’’ ( qut. in Mo. p. 10 ) . and this good describes the feelings of the 2nd coevals Asian-Americans. Therefore. since both immigrant parents and kids begin to alter mentally and physically for a better socialization. “ kids are less prone to experience embarrassed by their parents and more willing to accept parental counsel. thereby cut downing the likeliness of intergenerational struggle “ ( Foner. p. 8 ) ; in other words. intergenerational struggles would be minimized.
Finally. intergenerational struggles are inevitable in immigrant households. and these struggles frequently bring out confrontations. disagreements of values and premises. and letdowns of rebelliousness between immigrant parents and kids. Sometimes. intergenerational struggles may raise negative result and harm the relationship between coevalss. However. intergenerational struggles can be really reduced and the relationship can besides go tighter if both parents and kids try to alter their old point of positions. which are against each other. and show credence of different values and beliefs. In that instance. household relationship would bit by bit be strengthen and ne’er interrupt apart. Furthermore. if the society can lend and help immigrant households more ; for case. set uping free linguistic communication larning for immigrant parents who have jobs with English looks. or forming some consulting centres for immigrant parents to inquire for aid when there are struggles between them and their kids. If there are more aids and aid for immigrant households. intergenerational struggles would be reduced faster and earlier alternatively of waiting for the 2nd coevals turning as grownups. in which it would takes more clip.
Wu. Chunxia. and Chao. Ruth K. “Intergenerational Cultural Conflicts In Norms Of Parental Warmth Among Chinese American Immigrants. ” International Journal Of Behavioral Development 29. 6 ( 2005 ) : 516-523. Academic Search Premier. Web. 22 May 2012.
Foner. Nancy. Across Coevalss: Immigrant Families In America. New York University
Press. 2009. eBook Collection ( EBSCOhost ) . Web. 21 June 2012.
Lieber. Eli. et Al. “Ethnic Identity. Acculturation. Rearing Beliefs. And Adolescent Adjustment: A Comparison Of Asian Indian And European American Families. ” Merrill-Palmer Quarterly 53. 2 ( 2007 ) : 184-215. Academic Search Premier. Web. 14 June 2012.
Wang. Jenny Jiun-Ling. et Al. “Parent–Child Cultural Marginalization And
Depressive Symptoms In Asiatic American Family Members. ” Journal Of Community Psychology 34. 2 ( 2006 ) : 167-182. Academic Search Premier. Web. 14 June 2012.
Costigan. Catherine L. . and Daphne P. Dokis. “Relations Between Parent–Child Acculturation Differences And Adjustment Within Immigrant Chinese Families. ” Child Development 77. 5 ( 2006 ) : 1252-1267. Academic Search Premier. Web. 14 June 2012.
Mo. Weimin. and Wenju. Shen. “Home: A Feeling Rooted In The Heart. ” Children’s Literature In Education 38. 3 ( 2007 ) : 173-185. Academic Search Premier. Web. 14 June 2012.
Diwan. Sadhna. Sang E. Lee. and Soma Sen. “Expectations Of Filial Obligation And Their Impact On Preferences For Future Populating Agreements Of Middle-Aged And Older Asian Indian Immigrants. ” Journal Of Cross-Cultural Gerontology 26. 1 ( 2011 ) : 55-69. Academic Search Premier. Web. 14 June 2012.