The white abolitionist John Brown who has been thought of as a thief and in contrast a religious prophet led a raid at Harper’s Ferry in 1859. He attempted to start an armed slave revolt by gathering 16 whites and 5 blacks. They stole a numerous amount weapons held at the U. S Federal Arms. The raid was then stopped by a squad of U. S. Marines, that was led by Robert E. Lee. In my opinion John Brown was justified in the events of Harper’s Ferry because all of the violence he committed was for a greater greater cause
There were many reasons why John Brown was justified. First off by using violence as a self defense and defense of others Brown was stabbed by the U. S Marines defending himself and his men. Secondly, he was justified by using violence as a just cause. He did this by revolting to gain freedom for slaves. The third reason why his violence was justified is because it was for the right intent, Brown fought for a new government so the slaved could be rescued and protected.
John Brown Essay Example
The fourth reason why he was justified was by using violence as a last resort, the government refused equality of slaves to get freedom was to fight. The fifth Brown used violence was justified was because the revolting led to the civil war which ended slavery, therefore the revolting resulted in a greater good for many people. The last reason that was justified for violence was because of the probability of success. Instead of leaving his men to die he stood up and did whatever he could to guard the slaves while he was on the verge of dying.
On the other hand there weren’t as many reasons why Brown was not justified for using violence. To start he was not justified when using legitimate authority. The reason he was fighting was “by the authority of God Almighty” as Brown said which is not justified. Secondly he was not justified for his act of violence in the use of proportionality. This is because they captured innocent people that were not part the revolt. The last reason was that Brown went against noncombatant immunity by causing a guard to join their revolt, and when he refused to join he was shot.
This is not justified because Brown brought unarmed civilian into war that wasn’t supposed to be in war. I agree that John Brown’s violence was justified for the mere fact that the number of justified things overcame the number of things not justified. To start he was just trying to defend himself and others when being approached by the U. S Marines this is nothing but justified. Also he did all of this by revolting to gain freedom for the slaves. He did it for the better and I don’t see anything wrong with putting an end to people being treated like animals.
He was also justified when he fought the government so he could rescue and protect the slaves. Protecting others is the right thing to do at least in my opinion. Lastly I think he was justified because even while he was wounded and close to death he fought through it and tried to fight back to protect the slaves. That in my eyes is a person who is justified. Now this is from my own experience where I was justified. While in a snowball fight one of the opposing kids through a piece of ice instead of snow.
Of course this was prone to end in a bad result and did just that as it hit my friend in the eye. He reacted by running at the kid that through the ice and attempted to fight him. At first I didn’t know if I should step in or stand and watch. Then I reacted right after the first punch by my friend was thrown. I ran up to them both and pushed the other kid onto the ground away from my friend. I then pulled my friend away and brought him in my old apartment complex. The other two kids both walked home and my friend DJ came over.
I felt I was justified in this occasion because I only pushed the kid to separate them both and avoiding them from getting injured and was a greater good for the greater number. In the life of John Brown he was justified for his violence. He is deffinately a very important person in the United States as he aided in the abolishment of slaves. He did do something that was not justified but it did not compare to the amount justified. I think that John Brown should be known to everyone across the country as a great man with a even greater purpose. .