Book Review – Shanghai Gone This book is a harsh criticism China’s housing reform system for destroying Its own people, written by the author who observes China from liberal’s point of view. The author, Qin Shao wrote for those people who want to learn about the large-scale housing revolution in China throughout crucial experiences that citizens have gone through. It criticize the demolition and relocation system, questioning the level of morals.
We will write a custom essay sample
on Shanghai Gone Book Review or any similar
topic specifically for you
In Introduction, he gives concretely negative words of China’s abusing housing system and as he explains the historical process In order. For Instance, Shao escribes the government’s policies and Its corruption as “crucial,” “distrustful,” and he even calls them as “ugly twins. ” There are five chapters In this book; each chapter represents different victim’s experience of domicide. They are all based on the author’s long-term field research, focused and detailed in their several kinds of historical backgrounds, such as personal, family and community.
He was able to find that each “unique individual” had gone through different lives and their behavior was based on “their self-perceived identity, their values, their relationships to their omes, and their understanding of the reform. ” In Chapter 1, he writes about the woman who used to be a timid kindergarten teacher and was betrayed by the petition system, which she was seeking Justice. According to her family, her personality changed since she had had her eyes opened to become a petitioner and fight back for her family, herself, and Justice.
She gives her pride up for gathering public’s attention in front of the local government office; her high motivation became other citizens’ source of power. Chapter 2 is about the families who lost their homes and about their family history. Chapter 3 explains the outstanding case of neighborhood resistance to domicide in downtown Shanghai, involving a corruption scandal that compromises with the Shanghai CCP party boss and a “star businessman,” Christian lawyer. Chapter 4 is about the household clinging and the husband’s challenge to beat the system out.
The last chapter documents the neighborhood of Lincoln Lane, following their struggle for historic preservation.
Page 2 Shanghai Gone Book Review Essay
The author examines the grassroots, the Impact of media and law, the political and economical matters in historical preservation, and relationship between local protest nd the Influence of globalization. The useful recruitment devices tightened the bond of petitioners organizations though the government attempts to decrease the Influence of them. There are two kinds of domlclde; extreme and everyday.
In post-Mao era, people suffered In everyday domlclde -make parents give up about their children and leave their own hometown. It is very emotional and physically painful to the citizens who refused to leave their home regardless of their willing for historical representations or their actual legal land owner’s documentations. The author Shao insists that the physically painful to its people. There is an actual reported case that neighborhood, who had been resistant for China’s large-scale housing reforms, had been gone in a jail and had a hard time.
Moreover, there are forcibly evacuated people, who could not survive the different environment and had despair, committed suicides. He also brings up the fatal high-speed train wrecked in July of 2011 as an example of how the government disregard people and morals. However, the one thing that stands out for me the most is Chinese government’s ability to take control over its own people. They attempted the commitment, which allows its citizens of smaller things -although its aking control over people in bigger picture. This is a typical psychological method, which swindlers are good at.
Another example of psychological method that the government use toward petitioners is “black Jail,” the extralegal place of imprisonment where people can be confined for a long time without any access to legal protection. Depends on the prisoner’s “attitude,” their period of stay is determined; for leaders of petitioning organizations, it is more likely that their Jail time will be longer. The authorities force petitioners to sign the agreement to quit etitioning and keep their mouths shut about the abuse they get in the Jail.
Though it has been a big nationwide concern, officials deny the existence of black Jails. Shao insists that new Regulations are continuing failure; unlike previous one, the new Regulations focused on restricting petitioners instead of resolving “the root cause of popular grievances. ” This government’s misdirected petition system leads citizens to repeated petitioning -violence causes another violence. This spiral of hostility would not end unless the government decide to regard its own people highly instead of economic benefits.See More on Government